I Tried Martha Stewart’s Pumpkin Whoopie Pies — And Vanilla Made Me Cry

It started with a cold wind through the kitchen window and a bottle of vanilla I hadn’t touched since Christmas broke in half.

I wasn’t planning on baking.
I just… needed something sweet that clung to the air. Something soft in the center.
Something that let the smell of cinnamon and pumpkin do the heavy lifting for once.

I pulled up the old Martha Stewart Pumpkin Whoopie Pies recipe—because it felt right. Felt like something I could hold together even if I couldn’t hold much else.

What the Original Looked Like

Her Highness gives you soft, spiced pumpkin cakes with that signature clean Martha line between the halves. A neat cream cheese filling. Not too tangy, not too much. Just enough to remind you she’s in control.

She chills the pumpkin purée first. She sifts her sugar. She wants the whoopie pies to rise evenly, spread with grace, land soft.

And they do. Of course they do.
Her version is structured. Subtle. Almost smug.

But me? I was in a messy mood.

The Bit I Got Wrong (And Liked More)

I didn’t chill the pumpkin.
Used what I had. From the can. Straight in.

I swapped the dark brown sugar for the soft bag of light brown Mae used for her mug cakes last month. It clumped when I opened it. I smiled anyway.

And I didn’t sift the confectioners’ sugar.
Why would I? My mixer doesn’t care, and I wasn’t in the mood for rules.

I added a pinch of sea salt to the filling—the flaky kind from Provincetown, from a tin that still smells like a kiss I never talk about.

The Way It Happened in My Kitchen

The dry mix looked like October.
Cinnamon. Cloves. Ginger that hit the back of my throat harder than expected.

Mae came through the doorway, said it smelled like “Thanksgiving if nobody argued.” I almost cried at that.

The oil slicked in with a splash. Then pumpkin, vanilla, eggs.
I stirred too fast. Didn’t care. It felt like movement. Like something I could control.

I dropped the dough in gloppy heaps. Uneven. Cracked as they baked. Perfect, really—spiced pumpkin clouds with attitude.

The filling came last. Butter, cream cheese, sugar, vanilla—yes, that vanilla.
The same bottle from before the divorce.
The one that still smells like tree lights and grief.

I piped the filling between each cooled cookie, too much on some. Not enough on others.
Mae took one and whispered, “Actually good.”
That “actually” carried the whole day.

A Few Things I Learned

• The cookies taste better cold. Like memories do.
• If you let the filling sit a bit before piping, it firms up like a plan you’re finally ready to follow.
• Don’t skip the salt. In the batter or the filling. It gives the sugar something to hold onto.

What I Did With the Extras

Wrapped a few in foil and shoved them behind the kale.
One survived the night. Mae ate it cold before school and said, “Still good.”
Didn’t even ask what was in it.

Would I Make It Again?

Probably.
But only when I need something soft that looks like it held together on purpose.

That’s As Much As I Remember

The house stayed sweet for hours.
Cinnamon in the air, vanilla in the walls.
The kind of scent that lingers louder than voices.

I’ll make them again when the kitchen feels that quiet.

FAQs