I Tried Martha Stewart’s Pastry Cream, and It Reminded Me of the Cake We Never Made
Leave a Comment on I Tried Martha Stewart’s Pastry Cream, and It Reminded Me of the Cake We Never Made
Martha Stewart Pastry Cream
Leave a Comment on I Tried Martha Stewart’s Pastry Cream, and It Reminded Me of the Cake We Never Made
I wasn’t planning to make anything sweet.
but I opened the cabinet and saw the cornstarch.
the same kind my mother used to thicken stew.
and I remembered a birthday cake I was supposed to make with Mae.
we never did.
Martha calls it Pastry Cream—but to me, it’s that quiet custard you stir when no one’s looking.
the one that coats the spoon and your thoughts.
thick enough to hold a memory.
soft enough to slip away if you’re not careful.
What the Original Looked Like
Her Highness plays it by the book—milk, egg yolks, cornstarch, vanilla.
she says whisk constantly.
she says strain it if you need to.
she says use cling film to keep the surface smooth.
her version is classic. rich. barely sweet.
perfect for filling eclairs, cakes, tarts, maybe even regrets.
it sets up clean.
it behaves.
which is more than I can say for how I made it.
What I Did Differently
i used whole milk that was almost on the edge.
added a little more vanilla than I meant to.
didn’t strain it.
didn’t chill it long enough.
but it thickened anyway.
like it wanted to be remembered.
The Way It Happened in My Kitchen
the milk went on first—quiet heat, heavy pot.
i stood there, spoon in hand, not stirring yet.
just thinking about nothing.
then the sugar, slow.
egg yolks into the bowl like gold I forgot I had.
whisked without thinking.
the cornstarch made a mess.
dust cloud over the counter.
looked like the time Mae tried to make lemon bars and sneezed halfway through.
flour everywhere.
icing sugar in her hair.
i tempered like I meant it—slow milk into the egg mix, thin stream, no scramble.
then it all went back in the pot.
and I stirred.
and stirred.
until it got thick enough to coat the spoon.
then thicker.
like pudding.
like closure.
but it never quite closes, does it?
A Few Things I Learned While It Cooled
you’ll know it’s ready by the way the bubbles change.
vanilla smells sharper when you’re alone.
a rubber spatula can feel like a lifeline.
some desserts aren’t about sweetness.
they’re about silence.
What I Did With the Extras
filled a jar and forgot about it.
ate some cold with a spoon at midnight.
stood barefoot, fridge open, remembering.
froze the rest even though I knew it wouldn’t hold.
some things you freeze anyway.
Would I Make It Again?
yes.
not for a cake.
for a feeling.
That’s As Much As I Remember
the pot’s clean.
the spoon isn’t.
the memory still clings.
This reminded me of the lemon curd I made the day Mae stayed home sick. it never set. we didn’t care.
FAQs
yes. unless you like scrambled custard.
go slow. pour soft. keep whisking.
you can.
but it won’t feel the same.
fat carries memory.
no.
cornstarch gives it that soft glassy shine.
flour makes it dull. and heavy.
whisk like you mean it.
and never stop until it tells you to.
yes.
but it thickens in the fridge like grief.
you’ll need to stir it. gently.
Martha Stewart Pastry Cream – Nell’s Version
Description
Silky, warm, and just patient enough to remind you of someone who stayed too long. Stirred slow. Set soft. Sweet with something underneath.
Ingredients
Instructions
- Warm the milk slowly in a heavy-bottomed pot. add the first sugar. let it rise, but don’t let it boil. not yet. just steam and silence.
- In a bowl whisk the egg yolks and egg until they change color. pale. quiet. like they’re calming down. mix the other sugar and the cornstarch together, then add it to the eggs. whisk until smooth, like you mean it.
- Temper it—pour the hot milk into the egg mix in a thin stream. don’t rush. whisk the whole time. it’ll try to trick you, but you’re in charge now.
- Back in the pot it all goes. medium heat. keep stirring. no breaks. no thinking. just motion. it’ll thicken. then it’ll thicken more. then it’ll feel like pudding and look like something you want to keep forever.
- Turn off the heat. stir in butter and vanilla. keep stirring until it goes glossy.
- Spoon it into a bowl, press plastic wrap right onto the surface. no air. no skin. let it chill. or eat it warm, like I did. straight from the spoon.
because sometimes cooling it feels like waiting for something that never called you back.