I Tried Martha Stewart’s New York Cheesecake, and It Made Me Sit Still

I Tried Martha Stewart’s New York Cheesecake, and It Made Me Sit Still
Leave a Comment on I Tried Martha Stewart’s New York Cheesecake, and It Made Me Sit Still
Martha Stewart Cheesecake New York
Leave a Comment on I Tried Martha Stewart’s New York Cheesecake, and It Made Me Sit Still

this isn’t a quick dessert.
it’s a project. a meditation. a trust fall.
you mix. you bake. you wait.
and then you wait longer.

but when it’s ready—
when it’s cold, set, and clean at the slice—
you remember what it feels like to finish something worth finishing.

What the Original Looked Like

Martha doesn’t mess around.
seven blocks of cream cheese.
a crust made of grahams and butter.
a bain-marie that keeps the whole thing gentle and slow.

she tells you to chill it overnight.
she’s right.
don’t rush this cake.
it forgives a lot, but not impatience.

What I Did Differently

used digestive biscuits instead of grahams.
they crumble softer. I like that.

added a pinch of cinnamon to the crust.
not traditional—but comforting.

I didn’t have heavy-duty foil, so I used three thin layers.
still leaked a little.
still worked.

The Way It Happened in My Kitchen

crushed the crackers by hand.
poured in the butter.
pressed the crust with the bottom of a measuring cup, hard, like I was making something out of rubble.
froze it.
baked it.
let it cool while I beat the cream cheese until it sighed.

sugar and flour went in next.
then sour cream.
vanilla.
eggs, one by one—
just until they disappeared.

poured it all into the crust like it was a secret I meant to keep.
wrapped the pan in foil.
tucked it in a roasting pan.
poured boiling water halfway up the sides.

the oven took it from there.

45 minutes at 350°F.
then down to 325°F for another 30.
the top stayed pale. the center jiggled like a memory.
I turned the oven off, cracked the door,
and walked away.

an hour later, it was still warm.
but settled.
calm.

I chilled it overnight.
woke up to silence.
sliced it clean.

A Few Things I Learned While It Cooled

you can’t rush the chill.
you can’t fix the cracks.
but you can trust the rest will hold.

What I Did With the Extras

Mae took a piece with raspberry jam.
I froze three slices in parchment and foil.
ate one cold with coffee on the porch.
and that one?
that one was perfect.

Would I Make It Again?

yes.
on a weekend when I need something to take up space.
in the oven.
in the fridge.
in me.

That’s As Much As I Remember

the water bath leaked a little.
the top cracked near the edge.
but no one cared.
because it was real, and it was enough.

this reminded me of the cheesecake I served the first time Mae brought someone home. I was nervous. the cake wasn’t.

FAQs